Reviewed by Ray Simmons for Readers' Favorite
When I was a boy, World War II and the Korean war seemed closer.
They were something that had just happened and it wasn't that difficult to
find someone who had served in them, though getting them to talk about
it was sometimes a bit more difficult to do. Now those conflicts seem very
much a part of the past. The closest you can get to them is in the movies
and they seem no more real than dinosaurs or aliens. If you want a
closer look at the life and thoughts of an American soldier during the
Korean war, read The Reluctant Soldier by Marnie Mellblom. This is about
as personal as it gets. The Reluctant Soldier captures the feeling of that
time much better than a movie does. It seems we are inside the
characters’ heads and this can be priceless.
I liked The Reluctant Soldier on so many different levels. The characters
are interesting. The plot is straightforward and it’s easy to follow the story
line. Most of the places mentioned, like Japan, Korea, and Pennsylvania,
are places I have lived in or visited, and to my delight Marnie Mellblom
got them right. More than anything else, the writing is good in The
Reluctant Soldier. The descriptions of army life are dead on. It would
seem that some things never change. Most of The Reluctant Soldier is told
through the device of letters from Neal to his girlfriend and that seems an
appropriate way to tell a soldier’s story. It certainly worked for me.